Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Rebecca Shiner's avatar

Great article! I wonder how your perspective fits with AMPD Criterion A. I am less and less enamored with the trait model of PDs over time but still find merit in Criterion A.

Aussie Med Student's avatar

I admit I didn't understand your article... Though you lost me when you called 2 weeks of depression following the death of a partner as MDD (I'd call that normal grief) (if I'm not confusing this post with another)

Where does the stable bipolar individual who doesn't show psychoticism or neuroticism when euthymic... and has been euthymic on meds for years... how does that patient get categorised? At least with the current system, we know a bipolar patient has been manic, whereas I'm assuming there are plenty of high psychoticism / high neuroticism individuals who've never been manic... and maybe not even depressed. Presumably there must also be patients who've had severe MDD who have low neuroticism... again, where does a trait based nosology place them? And all the highly neurotic individuals who've never been severely depressed. (Particularly if we use the narrower, traditional meaning of melancholia.) Genuinely puzzled.

23 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?